War
So the terrorists gained a victory in Spain.
In some ways the March 11th attack in Madrid shook me up more than September 11th. The World Trade Center and Pentagon attacks were so shocking and immediate that my emotions misfired. I didn't know what to think, and I still don't to some extent. However, for whatever reasons, as an outsider and a self-described lover of Spain, I responded much more immediately to last week's attack in Madrid. I studied Spanish literature in college and I was lucky to briefly visit the country last year. I love Spain for its food, art, language, and, above all, its people. Because of this love, I admit that my true understanding of Spain is skewed by my romantic notions of it.
Then again, it seems to me that many Spanish voters just allowed terrorists to skew their notions of what Spain should be. I don't necessarily fault the Spanish people for electing Zapatero in hopes of withdrawing from the war on terror; the terrorist attack was timed perfectly to galvanize popular anti-war sentiment and funnel Spain's strong aversion to war into the voting booths. No, I don't fault the voters. I'm convinced that the trauma of the Spanish Civil War continues to haunt the hearts and minds of Spaniards, and I understand why they are so quick to avoid war. Nonetheless, I deeply lament their lack of resolve in the face of such gravity.
One of the first things I did upon learning of the attack was email some friends who live in Valencia. I met M, K and A while in Argentina about a year and a half ago. We spent almost three days running around Iguazœ falls together and we all quickly became good friends. Their warmth and love for life inspired me, and I count myself blessed to have met them. I hope to visit them in Valencia someday. M responded to me yesterday. She thanked me for my condolences and wrote the following:
"It's been tough, but it's no more than we're used to, and I'm not referring to terrorist attacks in Spain, there are so many injustices in the whole world!!!!! But it seems like we usually pay attention only to those that occur in the first world. Don't you agree?"
Of course I agree. I live in the first world, and I'm determined to make sure that injustices don't occur where I live. While I love M, I am dismayed by her response. The fact that injustice exists elsewhere in the world is no reason to get used to injustice on your home turf. I refuse to get used to it, I prefer to fight it.
That's not to say that I don't respect those who have chosen pacifism (Ghandi or Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. for instance), but we do not have a choice right now. Terrorists have chosen war, and those who refuse war have no choice but to let the terrorists have their way until they are no longer opposed. Of course, such an approach is entirely untenable. Personally, I refuse to let a small group of mass murderers determine how I will live.
Instead, today I align myself with those who believe that all are "created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" and that "to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their powers from the consent of the governed." Power is to be determined from the "consent of the governed," and I support anyone who is willing to fight those who believe that power is to be usurped through terror.
90% of Spain opposed intervening in Iraq yet Aznar went in anyway. If we truly believe in "consent of the governed" then he deserved to lose. The tragedy in Spain should be remebered throughout generations just as September 11th will be, but the candidate that Spain chose to elect should not be credited to Al Qaeda. Spain shouldn't be expected to keep around a leader that doesn't follow the voter's wishes simply to avoid "lack of resolve" in the face of terrorism.
Posted by: Marcos at March 16, 2004 07:59 PMMarcos, thanks for your comment. Aznar didn't lose this election, his chosen Popular Party successor did. Furthermore, polling before the attack showed that, despite the 90% popular opposition to the war, the Popular Party was expected to win the election. Spain apparently wanted to keep the Popular Party before March 11th. It's clear that the terrorists had a great deal to do with the rapid change of heart. Do you honestly believe that the attack had nothing to do with this?
As I said, I don't fault the voters. I can understand why they voted the way they did, whether it was out of fear or not. That doesn't mean that they did what I think is the right thing. No matter what their motivations for voting the way they did, the terrorists only see that their actions managed to persuade the country to vote so that their demands would be met (i.e. troops will be withdrawn from Iraq).
Posted by: Jed at March 16, 2004 11:48 PMWhat really bothers me about the swayed vote is that the terrorists got the reaction thy wanted and have even more reason to continue their attacks, because they work. Some people talk about how Zapatero is a socialist as if it is a huge change from the system they have now, but they already have government run hospitals and many other "socialist" type programs.
My big question for Jed is how will you (and the rest of us) stand up against terrorism? Is there anything that can be done other than join the group and take it down from the inside?
Posted by: Dave at March 17, 2004 01:02 AMI agree with Dave that the terrorists got what they wanted, jeopardized the elections and caused fear. What I don't understand is why voters changed their minds at the last minute when under the Populist Party Spain has gotten stronger than ever, with more jobs, better economy and healthier? I believe we can fight terror everyday, on our own little ways, not restricting ourselves because of it and living our lives normally. And making sure our world is more just to everyone, starting by living an honest life helping others whenever we can. I might be naive, but I do believe everyone has good inside of them.
Happy Thursday!
M
I like how the Bush administration is spinning this. Apparently, the people of Spain didn't cave in to terrorism after all. No, they threw a successful and pouplar government out because it mistakenly blamed ETA for the attack when it was Al Qaeda after all.
I'll vote for anyone who is willing to understand the world as it is as opposed to the world as they wish it to be.
Posted by: aporitic at March 19, 2004 11:53 AM